Sunday, September 30, 2018

High Stakes

St. Paul’s Church in Bergen & Church of the Incarnation, Jersey City NJ
September 30, 2018

Year B, Proper 21: The Nineteenth Sunday after Pentecost
Esther 7:1-6, 9-10; 9:20-22
Psalm 124
James 5:13-20
Mark 9:38-50

High Stakes
            Last week’s amazing, beautiful, and, yes, exhausting, celebrations sent me into one of the highest spiritual highs of my life.
            If you were there, maybe it was the same for you.
            Last Saturday’s consecration of our new bishop, The Rt. Rev. Carlye Hughes, was over-the-top spectacular.
            NJPAC was nearly filled with happy and thrilled people from all across our diocese and from the Church beyond. The stage was filled with bishops in their colorful regalia and an enormous choir – so big that no one seems to know exactly how big it was – over 200 voices for sure and maybe even more than 300, including a good number of our own choir.
            Before the start of the service, the liturgical dancers – including our own Patrice Maynard – dazzled the crowd with their choreography.
            And, at the end our own Gail Blache-Gill finally took command of that huge choir and blew the roof off the joint with nearly overwhelming performances of “Total Praise” and “Lift Every Voice and Sing.”
            And, at the heart of it all, there was Carlye Hughes: calm, confident, and joyful, ready to receive her blessings and to take on the heavy burdens of her office.
            That would have been more than enough.
            But, then, the next day, as you know, our brand-new bishop came and worshiped among us!
            It was a risky move to have an outdoor service in the middle of Old Bergen Road – and it was a ton of work, too, but my God, what a morning!
            Bishop Hughes is clearly a natural and I could feel – and I bet you could feel – a loving bond forming between and among us all.
            For me, the highlight of the morning was at the end of the service when the bishop invited us to turn and face out, to raise our hands, and to ask a blessing not just for ourselves but for that community – for the people gathered on the sidewalk, the people watching from the windows, the people who wanted no part of us, the people who had no idea who or what we are – or, at least, not yet.
            What a spiritual high.
            It’s a spiritual high that I can still feel, but, as always, we have to come down from the mountaintop.
           
I made my trek down the mountain on Thursday, and maybe you did, too.
I spent much of my day driving from one event to another, with my car radio on, listening to the Senate Judiciary Committee hearing – listening to the testimony of Dr. Christine Blasey Ford and Judge Brett Kavanaugh.
Dr. Ford was quiet, polite, obviously frightened, but also determined, and quite clear about the story of the long-ago assault that is still all too fresh in her mind.
And, Judge Kavanaugh was hurt and angry, fighting not only to salvage his Supreme Court nomination but also to clear his name of this charge.
Listening to all of this, I experienced a mix of powerful emotions: admiration, disgust, compassion, fear, sadness, anger – all of them churning in my gut and leaving me a little nauseous.
For the many, many people who have been assaulted and abused and for those who have been faced with the task of restoring their reputation, I’m sure Thursday was infinitely more difficult.
Over the course of that long day and since, I keep going back to how high the stakes were and are.
For Dr. Ford, there were the high stakes of losing her privacy and anonymity, subjecting herself and her family to scrutiny, abuse, and even danger - knowing that, just like Anita Hill, no matter what she accomplishes in her life, it’s for this that she will always be remembered.
High stakes.
And, for Judge Kavanaugh, there were the high stakes of keeping or losing the opportunity of a lifetime, the high stakes of holding on to a reputation, the high stakes of protecting his wife and children.
High stakes.
And, for the country there are the high stakes of somehow maintaining a democracy when our two political parties don’t just disagree on policy but openly despise each other, use underhanded methods to score victories, and no longer even attempt to understand any point of view other than their own.
There are the high stakes of a Supreme Court that has so much say over our futures.
High stakes.

This is all pretty obvious, I guess.
But, maybe less obvious – and even more frightening - is something else I started thinking about on Thursday:
For Dr. Ford and Judge Kavanaugh – and for all of us – the stakes have always been high.
The stakes are high when you’re 15 years old and go to an unsupervised party with a bunch of other kids, even just a year or two older – and there’s drinking, maybe a lot of drinking.
The stakes are high when you drink too much – so much that you fall asleep or pass out or can’t remember exactly what you did, but you have the sinking feeling that it might have been something terrible.
The stakes are high when you write hurtful, slanderous and stupid things in your yearbook and the stakes are high when the yearbook moderator – the adult who’s supposed to catch that sort of thing - overlooks it, maybe because that’s the school culture, or “boys will be boys,” or just because he wasn’t paying attention.
The stakes are high when we hold our pain inside and the stakes are high when we pretend to be something – someone - that we’re not.
And, yes, we might have missed it in the midst of last week’s celebrations, but the stakes are high for the Church that Carlye has inherited.
The stakes are high for those of us who have committed our lives and entrusted our livelihoods to a shrinking and shaky church.
And, the stakes are high for all of us because the Church can have such a powerful effect on people’s lives.
There are times that people come here and they are basically ignored. I’m not blaming anybody and it’s not usually intentional, but imagine the effect that can have on a person. Imagine the effect of going into God’s house, into a supposed community of love and nobody pays you any mind.
And, more positively, imagine the reverse: you go into God’s house and you can really feel God’s presence among people who really seem to be what they say they are.
High stakes.
And, there are high stakes down in Triangle Park – a neighborhood so long neglected that only really strong people could hold on to a sense of self-worth, only strong people could keep faith and hope.
When we told one local resident that our new bishop had chosen to come to his neighborhood, to his park, on her very first day, at first he couldn’t quite absorb, couldn’t quite process this news. But, once it finally sunk in, he said that he was so excited that it felt like when he was a kid and his parents said they were taking him to Great Adventure.
High stakes.
And, on Sunday when we turned and blessed the neighborhood, we raised the stakes even higher, proclaiming that God loves that place and its people, and promising that we are going to show that love in and through what we do.
High stakes.
Of course, Jesus, recognizes with perfect clarity just how high the stakes are  – that what we do or don’t do right here and now has lasting, even eternal, consequences for the world and for us.
That’s why Jesus is always so concerned about what’s going on in our hearts – he knows it’s a very short trip from our heart to our eye or our hand or our foot.
Jesus recognizes how high the stakes are for us, and so in today’s gospel lesson he uses some graphic language to make his point:
Jesus tells us: the stakes are high, so cut off whatever it is that causes you to stumble.

This is hard work and we can’t and shouldn’t do it alone.
With stakes this high, we need God’s help and we need to stick close together, to support one another, to look after one another.
Obviously, back in the 1980s in suburban Washington, several communities failed their young people in some catastrophic and long-lasting ways.
Today in Washington and across our country, our government is failing young and old alike.
And, all too often, the Church has failed – failed to protect the vulnerable, failed to speak clear words of justice and hope, failed to share the Good News in word and deed, failed to be serious about our work and mission.

It’s easy to get discouraged, but, you know, last Saturday in Newark and most especially last Sunday morning, right in the middle of Old Bergen Road, I was lifted into a spiritual high because I could feel, really feel, God’s loving and powerful presence in and among all of us, together.
Which is a good thing.
Which is the best thing of all.
Because the stakes are so very high.
Amen.