What a Difference
St. Thomas’ Episcopal Church, Owings Mills MD
August 30, 2026
Year A, Proper 17: The Fourteenth Sunday after Pentecost
Jeremiah 15:15-21
Psalm 26:1-8
Romans 12:9-21
Matthew 16:21-28
Well, what a difference a week makes.
If you were here last Sunday, you may remember that we heard what’s usually called “the Confession of St. Peter.”
In last week’s gospel lesson, Jesus asks his disciples, “Who do people say that I am?”
And the disciples share with Jesus what they’ve heard from others – some say that he is John the Baptist, or Elijah, or Jeremiah, or maybe one of the other prophets.
And then Jesus asks his disciples, asks his closest friends, a more pointed question, “But who do you say that I am?”
And, maybe to everyone’s surprise, maybe even to his own surprise, it’s Simon Peter the fisherman who gets the answer exactly right. Peter says,
“You are the Messiah, the Son of the Living God.”
Now, whenever I imagine this scene, I see Peter having a mix of pride and shyness. He knows that the others are looking at him, maybe some with admiration – “Way to go, Peter!” – and maybe others are looking at him with envy – “I should have said that” – or, my own favorite, “I was just going to say that!”
But it’s Peter who speaks the truth.
What a wonderful moment for Peter.
And then this moment gets even more wonderful.
Jesus tells Peter that he did not come up with this knowledge on his own, but it was given to him by God.
And then there’s this:
“And I tell you, you are Peter, and on this rock I will build my church and the gates of Hades will not prevail against it. I will give you the keys of the kingdom of heaven, and whatever you bind on earth will be bound in heaven and whatever you loose on earth will be loosed in heaven.”
Wow!
Now, I can’t get into Peter’s head, of course, but if I were in Peter’s sandals, I’d be feeling a little overwhelmed but also pretty good – I mean, God gave me this secret knowledge and Jesus has given me the keys of the kingdom.
If I’m Peter, all I can see ahead is glory: soon Jesus the Messiah, the Son of the Living God will sit on his splendid throne, and I, Peter, will be his right-hand man, standing beside him with the keys.
And that’s where we pick up today.
For the first time in the Gospel of Matthew, Jesus tells his disciples what is really going to happen to him – a very different kind of glory: Jerusalem, suffering, death, and rising again on the third day.
Imagine the shock of the disciples.
And I think Peter must have been so shocked that he stopped listening after “suffering” and “death” – he doesn’t seem to hear the part about “rising on the third day” – and out of shock and dismay and with great love for his Lord – and maybe also some fear about just what will happen in this scenario to the right-hand man with the keys – Peter “rebukes” Jesus:
“God forbid it, Lord! This must never happen to you.”
Now, at this point, we might expect Jesus to be pastoral toward his upset friend, you know, offer him some consolation, some reassurance, but instead Jesus “rebukes” Peter right back, with those now-famous words:
“Get behind me, Satan! You are a stumbling block for me; for you are setting your mind not on divine things but earthly things.”
Pretty harsh – way harsher than we would expect.
Maybe Jesus’ harshness is a sign that Peter touched a nerve – you know how something seems to only become real when you say it out loud?
Well, this is the first time that Jesus has spoken his fate, and he may very well be tempted to turn away – and Peter’s well-meaning words are definitely not a help – they are in fact a temptation.
No doubt, Peter had in mind worldly glory for Jesus – and glory for Jesus’ closest followers, very much including Peter himself.
But, following Jesus is not about worldly glory – it’s about carrying our cross – it’s not about gathering as much wealth and power as we can, trying to satisfy a hunger that will never be satisfied by more wealth and more power.
No, following Jesus is about giving away our lives in loving service to others, giving our lives away because, unlike Peter, we hear the promise of the third day – we know that, with Jesus, hate and death do not get the last word – we trust that, in the end, love and life win.
Of course, this can be hard to believe, difficult to remember, maybe especially these days, but every once in a while, we get reminded of what following Jesus is all about, sometimes in the most surprising people.
On Tuesday morning, I was in the jury waiting room at the Baltimore County Courthouse when my phone – and the phones of a lot of my fellow potential jurors around me – started buzzing with the sad news that Dolly Parton had died.
Now, I can’t say that I knew very much about Dolly Parton – of course, I knew some of her songs, I had seen some of her movies, I knew about Dollywood, and I had heard about her husband Carl Dean, who stayed almost completely out of the limelight during their long marriage. And I knew a little bit about her philanthropy that distributed books to children, Dolly Parton’s “Imagination Library.”
But starting with the whispers of my fellow jurors as they heard the news, I didn’t really grasp how much her life and now her death touched people – that, in a time when we can’t seem to agree on anything or anyone - here was a person almost universally beloved.
In today’s second lesson, St. Paul writes, “Let love be genuine.”
Well, as we’ve heard all week, Dolly Parton was beloved for her genuine love and care and her generosity – for example, her “Imagination Library” has given away over 332 million books to children over the last three decades – an unbelievable number - each one of those books a seed planted in a child’s mind and heart.
And she was also beloved because she stood beside the gay community ever since the worst of the AIDS epidemic, when so many others looked away, or ran away, or worse.
In the last few days there have been many stories of her kindness - and also her determination – some years ago, one CEO came out of a meeting with her and asked, “How can anyone say ‘no’ to her?”
And all this love, courage, determination, and confidence was rooted in her upbringing in the East Tennessee mountains, rooted in her faith – never forgetting where she came from, never forgetting who she was, never forgetting whose she was.
Apparently, she was an early riser – getting up at 3:00 to pray, often asking God two questions: “How can you use me?” and “What can I do today?”
That’s an awfully good prayer.
Her talent and drive earned her a lot of money, yes, but rather than becoming a billionaire, she gave away much of her wealth, gave away her life in loving service, bringing joy and hope, and a lot of fun, to so many people.
In the end, life and love win.
And what about Peter?
Well, for the rest of his life, he’ll show great faith and he’ll also make some big mistakes, especially in the moment when Jesus needed him most.
But in the end, this Galilean fisherman, he went all the way to Rome, where he gave away his life in loving service to Jesus, the Messiah, the Son of the Living God.
In the end, he was, and remains, the church’s rock.
What a difference a week makes.
What a difference a life – Peter’s Dolly’s, ours – with God’s help, what a difference a life makes.
What a difference a life committed to following Jesus – a life committed to genuine love and generous service – what a difference that kind of holy life makes.
Amen.








