St. Thomas’ Episcopal Church, Owings Mills
September 14, 2025
Year C, Proper 19: The Fourteenth Sunday after Pentecost
Jeremiah 4:11-12, 22-28
Psalm 14
1 Timothy 1:12-17
Luke 15:1-10
Everybody Counts, Everyone Matters
Last week, Sister June Favata died.
June was a Sister of Charity who devoted nearly her entire adult life, nearly her entire vocation, to St. Vincent Academy, an all-girls high school located in the center of Newark, New Jersey.
She arrived as a young nun in 1969 and played a key role in leading, sustaining, and developing the school until her health failed, just a year or two ago.
Thirty-three years ago, I applied for a position at St. Vincent’s as a history teacher. Fortunately, they called me in for an interview and so, on a memorable day, I rode the PATH train from Jersey City to Newark and then boarded a bus to take me from Penn Station to the school.
Back then, I didn’t really know Newark, so I was startled, even a little frightened, when the bus left the business district and moved deeper into the city where there were blocks and blocks of rubble, with the occasional lone building standing – I saw a city still scarred by the uprising that had occurred back in 1967 and the following years of disinvestment and abandonment.
Seeing all that devastation, I confess that I wondered just what I was getting myself into?
But I really needed a job, so I kept going.
Finally, the bus rounded a low hill and there was St. Vincent’s, a red brick 19th century building standing tall amid the empty lots and various efforts at urban renewal.
I spent most of that day with Sister June in her office.
She told me the story of St. Vincent’s, how, back in the late 60’s and early 70’s when lots of Newark institutions were closing or moving out to the suburbs, the Sisters of Charity and their co-workers made the decision to stay, and to keep on educating the girls of Newark and the surrounding towns.
Now, all these years later, that day is a bit of a blur, but I do remember two things that June told me.
One was that she saw the mission of the school in profoundly Christian terms. Yes, we were teaching these girls our subject content and life skills but really, we were playing our part in what she called “the ongoing redemption of the world” – that by teaching and nurturing these girls, we were continuing the saving work of Jesus right there in Newark.
And second, she was frank that this might sometimes be a hard job and, like at any school, occasionally my students might disappoint, frustrate, or even anger me, but I must always remember that each one of them was absolutely loved and cherished by someone – a parent, a grandparent, an older sibling – someone who loved them so much that they made the sacrifice to send them to St. Vincent’s.
And then she added, that even if that were not the case, each one of these girls was unconditionally loved by God.
And so, I should do likewise.
Back then, I didn’t know anything about the Baptismal Covenant and, as a Roman Catholic nun, I’m sure June didn’t either, but she certainly understood and lived the call to seek and serve Christ in all people, loving our neighbor as our self, to respect the dignity of every human being.
I wish I could say that I loved unconditionally during my five years teaching at St. Vincent’s (yes, I got the job!), or at any other time of my life, but I haven’t forgotten Sister June’s words, her teaching and example, which really was the teaching and example of Jesus.
In today’s gospel lesson, Jesus offers two parables, two parables that share a simple and obvious structure: lost, found, rejoicing.
And Jesus teaches us that the rejoicing of the shepherd and the woman is kind of like the rejoicing in heaven when a sinner repents.
Amen.
But, as I’ve sat with these parables during this tragic and disturbing week, a week when our need for repentance is more obvious than ever, a week when it feels like Jeremiah’s grim prophecy in today’s first lesson is being fulfilled, as I’ve sat with these parables, I keep thinking how both stories are… a little over the top.
Jesus begins by asking, “which one of you, having a hundred sheep and losing one of them, does not leave the ninety-nine in the wilderness and go after the one that is lost…?
Well, I’m pretty sure the correct answer is nobody – no shepherd would do that!
And the woman, sure, I get looking for the missing coin but then, after you find it, inviting your friends over for a party to celebrate?
I’m not the most social guy, but that seems like overdoing it.
But, with our summer reading fresh in my mind, and during this terrible week, this is the message I kept hearing in my heart:
Everybody counts.
Everyone matters.
And so, yes, that one sheep is so important that the shepherd risks a whole lot to find it and save it – and that coin matters so much that, yeah, when you find it, you throw a party.
Everybody counts.
Everyone matters.
This is not the way of the world, but it is God’s way.
For our over-the-top God, everybody counts.
And so, as Sister June and so many holy Christians down through the ages have understood and embodied, everyone, every precious human being, should matter to us.
So, Charlie Kirk and his grieving family, they count.
And the two students injured in the shooting at Evergreen High School in Colorado, they matter.
And Iryna Zarutska, stabbed to death on the Charlotte light rail, she counts.
And Minnesota legislator Melissa Hortman and her husband Mark who, along with their dog, were shot and killed in their home, they matter.
And Fletcher Merkel and Harper Moyski, the two children killed at Annunciation Church in Minneapolis, they count.
And Republicans, Democrats, Independents, and the many people who want no part of any of it, they matter.
And people whose ancestors arrived on the Mayflower and our Afghan friends, they count.
And people who are poor, rich, or somewhere in-between, they matter.
And people who are white, black, brown or any color, of any culture or creed, they count.
And people who are straight, gay, transgender, they matter.
And people we love and like and agree with and people we dislike or don’t understand or even fear, they count.
And hardest of all, the twisted, broken, violent people, the people poisoned by the internet, the people who say and do so many terrible things, yes, even they matter.
For God, everybody counts.
And so, for us, everyone must matter, too.
This is hard, believe me, I know, but we Christians are an Easter people.
We know – we know – that hate, suffering, and death do not get the last word.
So, let me tell you where I am finding Easter hope.
First, right here with all of you.
Last week was Renewal Sunday, but the truth is that our renewal is ongoing, the work of a lifetime.
We’re not perfect, but, week after week, there is so much faithfulness and devotion here, so much sacrifice, a warm welcome offered to everyone, an increasingly diverse group of people praying and serving together, loving one another.
We are playing our part in the ongoing redemption of the world.
This place matters – and you, all of you, count.
And reflecting on Sister June’s life and legacy has given me Easter hope, too.
Today, if you were to take that same bus ride through Newark, things look a lot different than they did 33 years ago.
Where there were rubble-strewn lots, now there are townhomes with carefully tended little patches of grass, there are new businesses and an expanded community college.
And when you round the low hill, St. Vincent’s still stands tall, but beside the old red brick building, there is a newer structure, one that was just a dream when I taught there, a building with state-of-the-art labs, a beautiful gym, and more.
And thanks to Facebook, I’ve managed to keep up with some of the girls I taught long ago – the girls who June taught me were treasured by their families, loved unconditionally by God.
And those girls are now women in their 40’s, working as doctors, teachers, nurses, lawyers, businesswomen, scientists – many of them are now moms raising their own families, with some sending their daughters to St. Vincent’s.
This is the power of God’s love, shared in and through people like Sister June, people like any of us.
This is the ongoing redemption of the world.
So, with the help of our over-the-top God, as we go forward together, may we always remember:
Everybody counts.
Everyone matters.
Amen.