St. Thomas’ Episcopal Church, Owings Mills MD
December 14, 2025
Year A: The Third Sunday of Advent
Isaiah 35:1-10
Psalm 146:4-9
James 5:7-10
Matthew 11:2-11
Poignant Questions
You know, it’s gotten very Christmassy here at St. Thomas’ – and that was even before last night’s snowfall.
Thanks to your generosity, many of the graves in the oldest part of our cemetery are now adorned with Christmas wreaths, a little touch of holiday love for those who have gone long before us, those no longer remembered by anyone still alive, but not forgotten by God, and not neglected by our church.
A really beautiful and meaningful tradition.
And last Sunday night, a bunch of us got together in the Parish Hall for “Carols and Casseroles.” Attendance was better than we expected, so we had to pull out some more chairs but, fortunately there was plenty of casserole to go around. After being fortified with hearty food and good cheer, we then went outside to sing “O Christmas Tree” as the little lights on our Christmas Tree brightened the dark night.
And then on Tuesday, even more of us came out for the Christmas Extravaganza, which once again lived up to its name!
We enjoyed yet another great meal and then we fanned out to the Library and the Old School Building to sort, wrap, and pack gifts for our neighbors who turn for help from the Community Crisis Center, Paul’s Place, ERICA, and Owings Mills Elementary School.
Just amazing generosity.
And then on Wednesday, we posted our Christmas banners out on Garrison Forest Road and St. Thomas Lane, a reminder for people who may not come to church very often, people who haven’t been to church since… Easter, or maybe even longer than that - a reminder to everyone driving by that Christmas is coming, and they are welcome here.
And, finally, even here in church today, there are signs that it’s almost Christmas.
Today, on the Third Sunday of Advent, what’s often called Gaudete Sunday from a Latin word meaning “rejoice” – on the Third Sunday of Advent we switch our liturgical color from blue to rose. It’s a kind of lightening up - a signal that, ready or not, soon it will be Christmas!
So, rejoice!
But …I have to say that, with that Christmassy spirit in the air, today’s gospel lesson doesn’t quite match the mood, right?
I mean, yes, John the Baptist is back, but his situation is quite different from what we heard last week.
Last week, John came out of the wilderness, clothed in camel’s hair and eating locusts and wild honey, deliberately echoing the Prophet Elijah.
Last week, John called the people to repent, to change their hearts, and, amazingly enough, the crowds thronged to the River Jordan to hear his hard preaching, to be dunked, and begin anew.
Last week, John had no use for the religiously respected, no use for people who thought that their station in life or their heritage would somehow save them.
And last week, John predicted the coming of one even more powerful than John himself, one who would baptize with the Holy Spirit and fire, one who will be a fearsome judge, armed with a winnowing fork, gathering his wheat into his granary and burning the chaff “with unquenchable fire.”
But that was then.
Today, we find John the Baptist in prison.
John had spoken truth to political power and, as usual, political power did not like that one bit and locked him up – and we know, and John probably knew, that he would not get out of prison alive.
And so, today we have this touching and unsettling scene of an imprisoned John the Baptist, once so confident and bold, who had baptized Jesus and recognized him as the One – an imprisoned John the Baptist sends his disciples to ask Jesus,
“Are you the one who is to come, or are we to wait for another?”
“Are you the one who is to come, or are we to wait for another?”
Why is John so uncertain now?
Well, I would imagine that being imprisoned with a looming execution will make you think, will get you thinking about what you really believe, what you can really hold onto when everything seems to be passing away.
I would also guess that a death sentence would make you acutely aware of time, would make John impatient for the Messiah to get to work already, pick up that winnowing fork and start separating the wheat from the chaff – if I’m wrongly imprisoned, I would want the day of God’s judgment to begin right this minute.
But that just didn’t seem to be happening.
And this brings us to a more sensitive explanation for John’s uncertainty about Jesus.
John wasn’t quite right about the Messiah.
John had anticipated a fearsome judge raining down fire, but, while it’s true that we will face ultimate judgment on the last day, God had a different kind of Savior in mind.
Jesus is a healer and a teacher.
Jesus came into the world to save the world, not to condemn it.
Jesus calls his followers to love, to give, to forgive, to cast out the evil spirits of the world.
A different kind of Savior.
And so, sitting in prison, John asked his poignant question:
“Are you the one who is to come, or are we to wait for another?”
And how does Jesus reply?
Well, in his usual way, Jesus doesn’t give a direct answer, but simply points to the work he has been doing, healing work that apparently they themselves had heard about and seen:
“…the blind receive their sight, the lame walk, the lepers are cleansed, the deaf hear, the dead are raised, and the poor have good news brought to them.”
We’re not told if the imprisoned John the Baptist accepted this answer, if he believed this evidence.
I hope so.
So, back to the people driving by our Christmas banners on Garrison Forest Road and St. Thomas Lane, the people who might consider coming back to church for the first time in a while.
Many will be drawn here by tradition and nostalgia. They’ll to see the beautiful decorations, to hear the familiar carols, to applaud our adorable and talented children as they act out the Christmas story.
But I think some of those people – maybe more than we might imagine – will arrive with poignant questions in their hearts, questions not unlike what John the Baptist asked long ago:
Is this Jesus for real?
Can I find hope and meaning here?
Are these Christians really who they say they are?
And we always try to do this as best we can, but at Christmas it will be especially important that we warmly welcome everyone who finds their way here, no matter what brought them here, no matter how long it’s been, no matter their questions, assumptions, uncertainties.
And on Christmas, the Weekly News and Notes will be even more important than usual, because it’s in those beautiful pages that we are able to tell some of our story.
And what’s our story? It’s a story of a diverse group of Jesus’ disciples with different ideas about all sorts of things, gathering week after week to pray and give thanks – welcoming absolutely everyone - offering ourselves in service to our community, in real and creative and sacrificial ways.
Our story is a story of people who love getting together, who love rejoicing, especially if there’s great food involved.
This is not bragging, just like Jesus was not bragging when he answered John’s disciples long ago.
This is the truth of God at work in, among, and through us.
And as an old friend of mine used to say, I don’t have to believe it, because I’ve seen it.
I’ve seen it here.
But there are so many people out there with poignant questions, people who haven’t seen it, who don’t believe it.
And so, we are called to tell them, to show them.
Especially at Christmas.
Amen.





.jpg)
.jpg)



